Menus
Fall Menu
Set Sail
-
Ne Clam Chowder
Chopped littleneck, classic seafood cream, smokey bacon bits, diced Yukon golds
Harborfest 2026 winner! $12.00
-
BBQ Ribs
Smoked baby back ribs, apple brussel slaw, house BBQ
$17.00
gluten free
-
Crab Stuffed Soft Pretzels
Warm soft pretzel sticks, jumbo lump crab, melted fontina
$19.00
-
Captain's Calamari
Golden fried calamari, lemon pepper dust, basil pomodoro marinara
$19.00
gluten free
-
Oysters on The ½*
Local North Fork oysters, kickin' cocktail, lemon
Available by the ½ dozen $18.00
gluten free
-
Brown Butter Mussels
PEI mussels, sherry brown butter broth, fennel, leeks, toasted baguette
1 lb portion $22.00
-
Jack's Buffalo Wings
Jumbo wings, Captain's buffalo sauce, celery sticks, creamy bleu cheese
$16.00
gluten free
-
Harvest Salad
Organic spring mix, crispy bacon bits, local apples, roasted pecans, shaved white cheddar, hot honey dijon vinaigrette
$18.00
gluten free
-
Captain's Caesar
Crisp romaine, sourdough garlic & herb croutons, grated cotija cheese, roasted anchovy caesar
$17.00
vegetarian
-
Country Brussels
Pan-fried brussel sprouts, diced country ham, apple cider butter, pepita biscoff crumble
$18.00
Sheet Creasers
All sheet Creaser's served with old bay fries & coleslaw; gluten-free bread available (+2)-
Fried Flounder Sandwich
Voodoo breaded flounder, champagne tartar, seeded rosette bun, lettuce, tomato, old bay fries
$22.00
-
Main Sail Burger*
Schiavoni's "Main Street blend" beef, toasted sesame bun, lettuce, tomato, choice of cheese, old bay fries
$20.00
Add Bacon $2.00
Avocado $3.00
-
Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Braised short ribs, mild cheddar, smokey pepperjack, pickled onions, toasted sourdough
$24.00
-
Blackened Mahi Reuben
Cajun caramel mahi-mahi, Captain's slaw, melted Swiss, coastal remoulade, toasted thick-cut rye
$25.00
-
Noyac Hot Chicken
Voodoo breaded chicken thigh, chili crisp sweet heat, pickle chips, shredded lettuce, jalapeño honey aioli, toasted sesame bun
$21.00
-
Jack's Hot Lobster Roll
Butter poached lobster, chive, tarragon, lemon pepper, toasted brioche roll
MP
Open Waters
-
Jack's Fish Tacos
Crispy fried codfish, apple brussel slaw, sliced avocado, maple sriracha aioli, warm corn tortillas, sweet potato French fries
$30.00
gluten free
-
BBQ Ribs Platter
½ rack smoked baby back ribs, house bbq, apple brussel slaw, fried green tomatoes
$32.00
gluten free
-
Shrimp & Grits
Sautéed jumbo shrimp, diced andouille, trinity veg, rich brandy cream, palmetto farms grit cake, shaved peppercorn asiago
$33.00
gluten free
-
Stuffed Fluke
Fresh local fluke, shrimp crab & scallop stuffing, lemon beurre blanc, roasted red potatoes, sautéed French beans
$38.00
-
Lobster Tagliatelle
Fresh lobster meat, silky lobster cream sauce, cherry tomatoes, roasted garlic, fresh herbs, tagliatelle
$42.00
-
NY Strip Steak*
Peppercorn-crusted 12oz strip steak, roasted red potatoes, pan-seared brussels sprouts, au poivre sauce
$48.00
gluten free
First Mates
Comes with kid's drink & an ice cream sandwich-
First Mate Fried Shrimp
Breaded shrimp, tartar sauce, plain French fries
$15.00
Adult size $8.00
gluten free
-
First Mate Pizza
Flatbread pizza, melted fontina, homemade tomato sauce, plain French fries
$14.00
-
First Mate Grilled Cheese
Toasted sourdough, melted American, plain French fries
$12.00
-
First Mate Pasta
Shell pasta, melted butter or marinara
$11.00
-
First Mate Burger*
3oz burger, choice of cheese, plain French fries
$14.00
-
First Mate Chicken Fingers
3 crispy chicken strips, plain French fries
$14.00
Adult size $6.00
gluten free
Port Sides
-
Captain's Slaw
$5.00
-
Old Bay French Fries
$7.00
-
Sweet Potato Fries
$8.00
-
Sautéed French Beans
$8.00
-
Toasted Baguette
$6.00
-
Roasted Potatoes
$8.00
-
Fried Green Tomatoes
$9.00
Starboard Sauces
Made in-house; +$1 each-
Jalapeno Honey Aioli
-
Sweet Heat
-
Captain's BBQ Sauce
-
Bleu Cheese Dressing
-
Coast Remoulade
-
Kickin' Cocktail
-
Maple Sriracha Aioli
-
Champagne Tartare
Specialty Cocktails
-
Autumn Mule
Better man American bourbon, cranberry juice, spiced cranberry syrup, fresh lime juice, Fever Ginger Beer
$18.00
-
Hibiscus Gin Sour
Better man lavender gin, hibiscus syrup, lavender simple syrup, fresh lemon and lime juice, egg white
$18.00
-
Cidertini
Stoli vanilla, apple cider, cinnamon simple syrup
$18.00
-
Harvest Spiced Rum Punch
White and dark rum, apple cider, blood orange juice, spiced cranberry simple syrup
$16.00
-
Pumpkin Spiced Espresso Martini
Espresso vodka, coffee liqueur, espresso, pumpkin spice syrup
$18.00
-
Captain's Fruity Margarita
Choice of: mango, strawberry, passionfruit, pomegranate, blood orange, apple cider, lavender, hibiscus
$16.00
Sober Sailors
-
Blood Orange N/A Mimosa
Blood orange juice, oui na sparkling wine
$15.00
-
Spiced Hibiscus Spritz
Hibiscus and cardamom syrup, cranberry juice, ginger beer
$9.00
-
Harvest Punch
Apple cider, pomegranate juice, cranberry simple syrup, fresh lemon, martinelli's sparkling cider
$9.00
-
Mango Bango
Mango purée, simple syrup, fresh lime juice
$9.00
-
Fresh-Made Lemonades
Mango, strawberry, passionfruit, blood orange, pomegranate, lavender, hibiscus
$7.00
Weekly Specials
Happy Hour
Tuesday -> Saturday 4:30-7pm-
2 for $22 Bar Menu!
-
$15 Burger & Beer
All day, every day, bar only
-
Wednesday - Fish Fry
Golden fried platters of your seafood favorites! Our signature voodoo-breaded flounder & shrimp served with our Old Bay fries and house-made tartar sauce!
-
Thursday - Lobster Night
1 ¼ lb. local lobsters steamed up with clams, shrimp, local corn & potatoes! What better way to kick off your weekend early!
-
Friday -> Sunday - Chef's Specials
Weekly chef's specials highlighting our amazing local produce & seafood- never the same, always delicious! The perfect way to spice up your weekend!
-
Saturday - Buck a Shuck
$1 oysters available at the bar starting at 4:30pm